Under the Sea Cookies.
Recently, I got the opportunity to make some truly adorable cookies! The baby shower theme was focused around Carter’s cute nursery line, “Under the Sea,” and I got to translate that into sweet cookies. π
I mean, how can you not LOVE this little guy?!
For the shower, my customer needed both take-home favors and cookies for munching on at the event. We decided that the sea creature characters would make great favors, so I made fewer of those. I made a large batch of smaller (2.5″ size) seashells, and my customer graciously allowed me carte blanche in how I decorated them. I chose to use the colors from the rest of our theme, creating a very special, bright & fun seashell assortment!
I designed my fish “character” to fit on an existing cutter I had. This is a purple plastic cutter from the Wilton 101 Shapes set, if you’re shopping. π
For the cutie-patootie whale character, I used the whale cutter from the above-mentioned set, and I pieced it together with one of my small-ish heart shapes to create enough space to allow for the chubbier shape, as well as the little water spouts at the top. I love it so much!
The seahorse design was also modified to fit on an existing cutter, again from the Wilton set above. I pieced the shape together with a small scalloped circle to allow for the fringe around the seahorse head. My customer ordered a cake in the shape of a onesie, and then she placed one of these seahorse cookies on top as the decoration, even — TOO cute! <3
Sometimes, I want to travel along with my cookies & see the special events they get to be a part of. For this sweet “Under-the-Sea” set, that was DEFINITELY true! π

Love your cookies Nicole!
Thank you so much, Michele! π
I am having my daughter in law baby shower Oct 17 and was wondering if you could do the cookies under the sea carters theme. She is having a girl and that is here theme
Hi Debbie! I’ve sent you an email. π
My friend is having her baby shower in March I would love her to have your cookies there. They look amazing. Is there anyway of me getting in touch with you.
Thank you.
Hi Danijela! You can send me an email – nicole@lifesabatch.com – for order requests. Please be sure to put the date of your event in the subject line of your email. Thanks so much! π
Hello Nicole,
I love these under the sea cookies!!! I have my daughter’s birthday party on June 18 and I was wondering if you could make them for me? Could you please tell me what size cookie the octopus and seahorse are? Thank you
I love the octopus cookie! Where might I find that cutter?
Thanks:0)
Hi Tracey! My octopus is a plastic purple cutter from this set: http://www.amazon.com/Wilton-Animal-50-Piece-Cookie-Cutter/dp/B0000VMITA/
Hope that helps! π
I love the whole under water theme. Especially the Sea Horse.
Where might I find that cutter? Thanks –
Hi Lee! My plastic seahorse cutter came from this Wilton multi-pack: https://www.amazon.com/Wilton-Animal-50-Piece-Cookie-Cutter/dp/B0000VMITA/
Happy shopping! π
Hello,
I would like to order these Under the Sea Cookies for my daughter’s baby shower in September. How do I order them?
Claire, I have emailed you. π
My friend is having a baby shower that is this exact theme. I was wondering more about prices and quantity. Thanks!
Shelby, I’ve sent you an email. π
Been looking at these for months now. Finally getting things together for her baby shower on 9/3, would love sea theme cookies for a girl. Please contact me, your cookie are awesome
Hi Shirley! I’ve sent you an email. π
Hi, I’m interested in your seahorse cookies. Can you please send me info with prices. Baby shower is August 27, 2016. Thanks!
I’ve just sent you an email, Michele. π
Hello! I was interested on the cookies and wanted to orde some!
Hello Maribel!
Please feel free to send along any order requests in a NEW email with your party date in the subject line to this address – nicole@lifesabatch.com
I’m happy to help! Thanks for thinking of my cookies! π
i would like a variety of these Under the Sea cookies for approx 50 people what are the costs and shipping fee to Moreno Valley California
Thank you
Hi ! I’m throwing a small baby shower for my sister on 6/16/18. There will be about 10 of us here. Could you email me a quote please? She’s having a baby girl and I want to do an under the sea theme, these are the colors/nursery theme https://www.target.com/p/baby-girls-3pk-pants-cloud-island-153-mint-blue/-/A-52375996
I sent you an email. π